14 Comments
User's avatar
aestevez's avatar

Mr. Christgau,

At the risk of a B- being downgraded, I humbly request you’d consider revisiting Todd Rundgren’s A Wizard, A True Star.

Expand full comment
Kent Gibbons's avatar

I guess we have whoever sued Lennon on behalf of Chuck Berry to thank for inspiring this newly "A" ranked classic into our midst!

Expand full comment
wwolfe's avatar

That would be Morris Levy, a truly shameless criminal in a business that produced more of that class per capita than any other field, except perhaps the 19th century railroad game. He inspired two indelible portraits, first in the person of the music biz honcho in The Sopranos and, even better, in Tommy James' lengthy description - equal parts loving and horrified - in his autobiography, Me, the Mob, and the Music.

Expand full comment
Kent Gibbons's avatar

Doesn’t sound like Morris will get an upgrade from Bob.

Expand full comment
Ryan Maffei's avatar

I think you were right the first time: "mysteries of emotional and rhythmic commitment” was spot on. Lennon sounds exhausted, and the backup sounds overloaded and incoherent, whether or not Phil or John is responsible for it. I think the "Stand By Me" is an eternal classic, the "Bony Maronie" works in a mad tea party way, and everything else topples on its face or backwards, to say nothing of justice not done to raw, off-the-cuff classics. But though I think ranking this with Plastic Ono Band and Imagine is a momentary lapse of reason, I give your affection an A. There are worse things to make peace with than this LP, and worse singers to love unconditionally than John Winston Ono Lennon.

Expand full comment
walter cherrette's avatar

Now that i noticed his own version of that Teddy Bears classic (for myself at age 5 anyway),maybe that whole album was also dedicated to Yoko.Not to impress us ,R&R's who knew all of those song too well.And still do when i'm listening to them now.But that guitar break on "Peggy Sue" could have been a lot better.

Expand full comment
Michael Tatum's avatar

For those who care about box scores, Xgau originally described the outtakes to “Rock N Roll” that later appeared on “Menlove Avenue” as “stiffer than the intakes.” Almost thirty years later, when he reviewed the “Rock N Roll” reissue bonus tracks, he picked out two of those songs as “choice cuts.” So I think he warmed up to that record a long time ago, he just didn’t know it.

Expand full comment
Postcards From Home's avatar

Lists are a really bad idea to begin with, (see Dave Letterman) but that vocalists list belongs on a Top 10 worst best. And it’s time to just let Lennon and the Beatles be. We’ve heard them enough already. There’s plenty of other music worth listening to, old and new.

Expand full comment
Tom Roedel's avatar

Is there an argument being made here? Sadly, it’s the brevity of Lennon’s post-Beatle output that can lead to grade inflation. Just because (no pun) we’ve been in a bit of a nightmare since 12/8/80 doesn’t retroactively redeem this one necessarily. It was at the time a stark comment on Lennon’s exhausted muse (he hadn’t had a truly worthy album since 1971). Spector overdid everything as usual, but there was at least some character to his production - Lennon tried without success to ape that grandiose production but ended up sounding hollow (his mimicking of Spector was better on Pussy Cats). Rock ‘N’ Roll is a sad retirement package from an artist who had burned too bright but eventually lost the plot. Then after losing said plot he retreated to making an oldies album and retiring. Double Fantasy/Milk & Honey showed a hint of spark and who knows what might have come after?

Expand full comment
John J. Winters's avatar

"Just because you left and said goodbye..."

Always dug that one...

Putting it on right now!

Expand full comment
Joe Ivory Mattingly's avatar

I’m rather fond of John Lennon’s Rock and Roll myself

Expand full comment
Matt Guerra's avatar

Great stuff but I'm a little confused by the opening paragraph -- why was this B- in your A shelf to begin with?

Expand full comment
Ray's avatar

Paul did a great cover of It’s So Easy. Maybe better than anything on John’s rock n roll album.

PS If we talking about past mistakes, you never did review ‘Til Tuesday’s Everything Is Different Now. Which is a A easily in my book

Expand full comment
Carsten Rasch's avatar

Going to give John a second chance, too ;)

I’m surprised though that Tom Jones isn’t ranked among the top vocalists on anyone’s list.

Expand full comment